The same shots, sprint by sprint

Twelve story moments of the held-out episode. For each: the manga panel, the generated shot from every sprint, and the shot of the real episode that adapts the same moment. Every clip is silent.

Manga panelSprint 1: colourised panel + Wan 2.2Sprint 2a: Illustrious keyframes + video LoRASprint 2b: same keyframes, base video modelSprint 3: script-firstSprint 4: reference-drawn framesSprint 5: style references, reframing, 16 fps, editor passReal anime (reference)

A sample is a real shot for which every sprint has a counterpart (dialogue and visual alignment, confidence at least 0.8). 88 qualify; twelve were picked by eye for clear correspondence, not for quality. Method, full tables and caveats: eval/README.md.

1. Chapter 114: Nakanaka stares wide-eyed and red-faced at Agari's radiant smile

3 s · alignment confidence 1.00 · line: “R—”

Sprints 1 and 2 draw the wrong girl: the panel-by-panel reader did not know who was in the panel. From sprint 3 on the character is right (eyepatch, bob). Sprint 5 frames her as the close-up the show uses.

2. Chapter 114: Katai stands in the doorway, enormous and scowling, students shrinking back

6 s · alignment confidence 0.97 · line: “I'm gonna say 'good morning' to everyone today for sure!”

Sprint 1 keeps the manga layout almost unchanged. Sprints 4 and 5 hold the cast and the room from the shots before. The real shot carries the show's name lettering, which the pipeline does not draw.

3. Chapter 114: Tadano turns in his seat and smiles easily at Katai, whose back fills the foreground

6 s · alignment confidence 0.98 · line: “Oh, good morning, Katai-kun.”

Sprint 5 looks past Katai's shoulder at Tadano, close to how the real shot is staged; earlier sprints put both side by side.

4. Chapter 114: Tadano gives a small, reassuring nod and a gentle smile

3 s · alignment confidence 1.00

Sprint 4 drew this close-up as a boy at a desk in a wide classroom: the painter frames everything a size too wide. Sprint 5 crops finished frames to shot sizes measured on the show.

5. Chapter 116: Komi hides behind her raised notebook while Onemine smiles at her from the right

4.38 s · alignment confidence 1.00 · line: “You paused for a bit there.”

The notebook is Komi's voice. Sprints 4 and 5 write it in English inside the frame, as the pipeline's language is English throughout; the real episode writes Japanese.

6. Chapter 116: Otori leans in with clasped hands as Onemine turns to her with a warm grin, Komi watching

6 s · alignment confidence 0.84 · line: “Can I~ come too~?”

Three girls, and until sprint 3 at least one of them is someone else. Sprint 4's reference-drawn frames get all three right and keep their clothes from shot to shot.

7. Chapter 117: Najimi bursts through the classroom door with both arms flung wide, scarf flying

4.05 s · alignment confidence 0.90 · line: “Hello! Happy Valentine's!”

The header image of the repository. Every sprint understood the entrance; the look moves from flat manga colouring to the show's palette. The real shot adds motion lettering.

8. Chapter 117: Komi offers a chocolate bag and Yadano takes it with both trembling hands

4 s · alignment confidence 0.81

The least certain alignment of the twelve (confidence 0.81): the generated shots and the real one may be neighbouring beats of the same hand-over, and the recipient differs.

9. Chapter 117: Katai stands over the desk, flushed crimson, one hand still on the chocolate ribbon

4.25 s · alignment confidence 0.95 · line: “...It's a friend chocolate.”

Sprints 4 and 5 put the scene in an evening classroom and keep Katai on model, but give him a necktie the show never does: a costume error sprint 6 reads off the show's own character picture.

10. Chapter 118: Two empty swings hang side by side in a small park at dusk, bare winter trees behind them

3 s · alignment confidence 0.98

An empty set. Sprint 1 colours the panel as a bright day; from sprint 4 on the frame follows the script's dusk. The real episode plays the scene later at night.

11. Chapter 118: Komi looks down bashfully beside Tadano's wide, astonished eyes in a split close-up

5.09 s · alignment confidence 0.85 · line: “...It's... it's a friend chocolate...”

The manga's split close-up. Sprints 1 to 2 keep the split; sprint 5 restages it as a two-shot with the scarves the script gave them. The real shot is an extreme close-up in near darkness.

12. Chapter 118: Tadano stands stiff on the path, gripping the railing, mouth open in a cracked reply

4 s · alignment confidence 0.99 · line: “Y... yes!?”

A reaction shot. Motion is the difference between sprints 4 and 5 here: the earlier clips were played at 8 drawings a second, sprint 5 at 16.

Numbers

What was measured

12a2b345Real
FVD against the real episode (floor: another real episode = 321)470326–333326–333346514390—
First frames, distance to the real episode's (KID ×1000)—0.120.120.130.510.28—
First frames accepted by the cast check———157 / 286284 / 286316 / 316—
Cuts that stay in the same scene—53 %—76 %94 %92 %91 %
Continuity errors per 100 same-scene cuts—7.1—10.01.62.31.2
Mean optical flow————0.090.330.73
Clip against its animatic, automatic vision judge201 : 86155 : 137212 : 94—276 : 9289 : 15—
Clip against its animatic, independent blind rater (40 pairs)————27 : 628 : 4—
Generated against real, two blind raters: generated side recognised————160 / 160160 / 160—
The raters are AI models; a human has rated 6 pairs. One series, one held-out episode, one generated episode per sprint: differences of a few points are not findings. Details in eval/README.md.